I could easily think of several dozen hitters I'd rather have up than Jeter. Care to name a few? I would also take Pujols also. excluding ortiz and pujols: derrek lee, a-rod, travis hafner, manny ramirez, carlos delgado, todd helton, jason giambi, jason bay, vladimir guerrero, mark teixeira, miguel cabrera, ken griffey jr, morgan ensberg, lance berkman, adam dunn, aramis ramirez, andruw jones, jim edmonds, chase utley, david wright, chad tracy, richie sexson, paul konerko, brian giles, brian roberts, michael young, pat burrell, gary sheffield, jeff kent, geoff jenkins, nick johnson, jhonny pheralta, troy glaus, david delluci, bobby abreu, matt holliday, miguel tejada, mike sweeney, cliff floyd, hideki matsui, randy winn, jason varitek, victor martinez, and jermaine dye. And I'm not sure I wouldn't take a few people coming out of retirement... Larry Walker certainly... maybe even Tony Gwynn or Don Mattingly And what exactly have all of those players done in the postseason or in clutch situations in general to make them so scary? I'm would be afraid if I was a pitching in an important situation if Ortiz, Pujols or Jeter was coming up. Would I be afraid if ARod was coming up? No because I know ARod gets all of his HR's and RBI in 15-2 blowouts of the Devil Rays. It depends on situations. Is Jeter the best hitter in the league? No. But he comes through in the clutch. Maybe not every time, but nobody does.