No thank you. I don't need some 3 or 4 loss team to get in just because they won a weak division and got lucky in the conference title game. Does that happen often enough for that to be a legitimate concern every year? I doubt it. Also, if some 3 loss team Cinderella's their way into the playoff, so be it. 2016: Virginia Tech (9-3) 2015: USC (8-4) 2013: Duke (10-2 but ranked No. 20 going in) 2012: UCLA (9-3), Wisconsin (7-5), Georgia Tech (6-6) 2011: UCLA (6-6) 2010: South Carolina (9-3), Florida State (9-3) 2009: Nebraska (9-3), Clemson (8-4) Those weren't winners but they were conference championship game participants. One win from getting in. Hard pass on that. If it was top 8, I could get on board. But to me, 4 is fine. Reward excellence throughout the entire season. I've always liked that college football differed from the other sports in that way.