You did miss that part, and also the part about the guy we had playing 2B last year not being able to repeat his production from last year. sounds familiar to what was said about him last year Even if DeRosa repeats, Roberts is a superior player. Click me Agreed that Roberts is the better player, but I'm thinking that DeRosa isn't going to play SS, in which case we're giving away trading chips for a marginal upgrade at 2B. The real upgrades need to be either at SS (preferably) or CF. It's a value proposition. With Roberts in tow, you can play DeRosa at SS(where he has value even if he regresses offensively), you can use him as that super-sub(where he replaces 300 PA's of replacement level production, and offers better than terrible protection against injuries), you can use his ability to mash against LHP to protect Pie(although that requires Kosuke playing some CF), or you can sell high on his performance the last two years to upgrade elsewhere.