People in this thread who said Peavy was as good or better than Santana: Meph, Rob People in this thread who expressed reservations about trading for Peavy, and/or disagreed with Meph/Rob's characterization of him: I don't want to go back and count, it's over half a dozen. You're embarrassing yourself with this over-the-top "what is wrong with everyone why does everyone think this thing that is clearly wrong and I must bombastically correct you for the error of your ways" schtick. You're exaggerating. Over half a dozen? I think not. That is over the top. You may call it bombastic posting, but if you feel strongly about a subject I don't see a reason to put a little verve into it, instead of everyone trying to out Spock/robot each other. Plus, in order to get embarrassed I would have to care about the reputation of this little internet persona, which I don't. I basically get ganged up on about petty nonsense in nearly every thread I post in, oh no, I'm not proclaiming Jay Jackson is Tim Lincecum just yet, I'm such a negative guy, everybody pile on. That's part of what I don't like about these boards, what starts as a one-on-one disagreement turns into 7 people taking cheap shots at you personally instead of your argument. I just wish there was less damn posturing. Uh-oh, somebody thinks the fact that Josh Hamilton recovered from drug addiction does not make him a better baseball player than if he never took drugs in the first place! Better send out 10 guys with "internet tough guy" attitudes to deal with the problem. Off the top of my head, two people objected to Rob's characterization of Peavy/Santana as 1/2, one citing Webb, the other citing Halladay/Lincecum. Mhuber posted that he wasn't all that enamored with Peavy, citing his maximum effort delivery. Two people, including myself, talked about Peavy's less than sparkling away splits, and UMFan agreed with me when I brought it up. So there's your half dozen, I'm sure there's more. The reason lots of people respond to you is because you make up arguments and apply them to the whole board, and you do it with a very aggressive tone. I'm sure you'd find much better conversation if you left it at "Josh Hamilton doesn't deserve to be in the top 10 in MVP voting" as opposed to "why do all you mouthbreathers think Josh Hamilton is in the Top 10 in the AL?"