And they all missed the playoffs. Considering that the defense for these intentional losing seasons is that we're going to have a long run of making the playoffs at the end of them, considering how likely that long run is should factor pretty heavily into assessing the merits of the plan. If we throw away three seasons waiting on the impact wave of homegrown talent, then have a couple of 89- or 90-win, no-playoff seasons after, pretty soon the math just doesn't add up. The playoff probability per win in the NL and AL are different, I'm pretty sure you know that. 89-90 wins in the NL is MUCH different than the AL. Being the supposed all-know fan you are I thought you would know this by now. "The most valuable wins to a NL club were typically wins 87 through 91, which increased a team’s playoff chances by 57 percentage points." "In the American League, because the two super-powers—NYY and BOS—typically upped the ante for the wild card, the highest leverage wins tended to be wins 90 through 94." 90 wins in the NL gives you a much higher chance to make the playoffs than it would in the AL.