Wait, you guys are arguing about the short/long term ramifications of trading Marmol? Trading Marmol is a no-brainer,imo. Trading him does little or nothing to hurt the team right now, as there are in-house candidates to replace him, because he was fairly bad at his job last year and because his arm may well be ready to fall off. Virtually anything we get for him will be a net gain. Trading Marmol and trading a guy like Garza are completely different scenarios that need to be assessed differently. Just because you apply a line of thinking to the trade of one asset does not mean it has to be applied as the approach to all trades. And yes, the notion that Theo and Jed are at the mercy of whoever calls and makes an offer is ridiculous. They can and likely would seek out a trade partner who matched up well.