Well, I did take a minimal stance that of this minute in time, today, I dont see Rich contributing to the Cubs organziation anymore. So are there any other conflicting viewes? Some saying he is a dead horse, some saying one pitch rich can rise from the ashes of VWL to rejoin the Cubs People always argue semantics, especially with sports. Cant be avoided. But I certainly would never try to start arguments. Disucssions, argumemnts...two different things. And thats really why I didn't appreciate TmT's first reply to this thread. Factually devoid of any kind of hard number made arguments, what we got instead , was three lines on a post with zero purpose. I'd delete it, if I could. Pisses me off if the up and ups uses less-posting members threads as test toys or whatever. There are valid reasons as to why one could expect Hill to come back, we haven't seen him since he was shut down and whether or not his problems are mechanical and only FB related or mental ala Blass. I'd rather see him screwed up mechanically with his FB and still have the same break on his CB. He'll never have great command and control, his delivery will always restrict that, there are too many parts moving and with that shoulder tilt ala Guidry, everything has to be aligned perfectly. Hill was strong before this last outing which indicates more physical (mechanics) than mental, he's worth keeping in the organization even with his "one pitch" although his FB generates plenty of swings and misses given how good his curve is and how well he hides the ball. I'm not counting on him coming back, the Cubs aren't either, but hopefully like the Cubs I wouldn't give up just yet on him given how good he was in '07 with one pitch and poor command.