Yes, because clearly Ryan Jorgensen and Jose Cueto blossomed into perrenial all stars and the Marlins completely and utterly fleeced the Cubs. Look, I did not make the claim that these guys were flawless; they've made their share of screwups and I'm more than happy to hold them accountable for it. Bringing Jose Macias back and giving him a raise, for example. But, in that particular instance, I think the the vast majority of people out there did not think that Willis would become a Cy Young contender. At the time, he was a throw-in. He had horrible control issues and excessive wildness. Most people saw him as becoming a 4/5 starter or a LOOGY when all was said and done. His delivery didn't exactly inspire confidence about his long term health, either. Clement gave the Cubs three good years and helped propel them into the playoffs in 2003. Has Willis stayed with the Cubs, I'm almost positive he would not have seen the majors that year. Remember, at the time he was called up, the Marlins were seen as being out of it and ended up calling up anyone with any degree of promise. Had he stayed with the Cubs, I don't know if any of us could quite say what his career would look like right now, whether he'd be in the pen or the rotation or injured or whatever. Plus, if anything, Willis gives those guys their share of credit. The Cubs actually did draft him and help him develop, ya know? You don't think other teams out there are looking at the Cubs' farm system right now wondering if there's another Dontrelle Willis in there? It definitely makes the Cubs farm system look a lot better. The Cubs didn't end up becoming the winners of that deal, I'll grant you that. But there were enough positive results out of it that I wouldn't call it an utter disaster like some people on this board would.