For one, yes, it is open to criticism because of the fact that nearly every single player on this freaking list is white. You can find plenty of non-white players of comparable talent and production to all of the guys on this list on pretty much every team. Tell me, what makes David Eckstein any more deserving of an award like this than, say, Yadier Molina? Or John Mabry as compared to Henry Blanco? Secondly, this list seems completely arbitrary. The list ranges from halfway decent players (Westbrook) to 25th men at best (John Mabry). What exactly qualifies a guy for a list like this? Is it because John Mabry once told a joke that made Aramis Ramirez feel better after Rammy got a parking ticket downtown? Is it because Kevin Youkilis once took a 45 minute detour to get the Red Sox 10 dozen donuts with sprinkles from Dunkin Donuts before practice one day? Finally, while Cardinals fans are welcome here, you may want to tread lightly. Comments such as your first post in this thread usually are bad omens for posters such as yourself.