I have to make my keeper choices tonight and could really use some feedback.
For some context: 12 teams, 0.5 PPR, superflex (basically 2 QB) start 3 RB and 4 WR. QB passing TDs are 6 points. It's a very big QB league. Unfortunately I don't have a good QB keeper option because Kyler tore his ACL and Fields was a keeper last year (can only keep 1 consecutive year).
Here are my best keeper options and what round I would lose a pick in if I kept. I have to pick 2
Barkley (Round 3)
AJ Brown (Round 4)
Garrett Wilson (undrafted so Round 8 )
Ridley (undrafted so Round 9 )
Pacheco (Round 16)
I also have Jefferson (R1) and if I really wanted a QB Pickett (R13) but nah.
Wilson I'm almost certainly keeping. In my mind its between Brown and Ridley. Brown gives me WR1 value from Round 4 but he was unusually healthy last year and D. Smith took some of his value away later in the year. Ridley is a huge wild card but has WR 1 potential with a 9th round pick, but his floor is riskier due to the 2 years of layoff and the Jags pass catching options.
I suppose Barkey is an option too, but I don't trust him after seeing him wear down at the end of last year.
So really unless someone feels differently its between using a 4th round pick on AJ Brown or a 9th round pick on Calvin Ridley. Thoughts??