No, I was arguing with the assumption that your statement was correct, which I do not believe it is. For the record, considering his superior defense (not arguable) and the likelihood that statistically he would put up much better power numbers with any team other than the Padres (this is my opinion based on statistical analysis but can be argued), I would put Greene just in front of JJ Hardy on that list, assuming that your list is in order and not just a list of SSs that are better than Greene.