I'm sorry I cannot in good conscience take Buff over Sharp. I realize the value that Buff brings, but Sharp is simply a better and more consistent player. Also you said the roster doesn't include Brouwer, but Brouwer is in the projected lines. Why couldn't Keith have won the conn smythe grr. Re: Sharp vs. Buff - if the cap hits aren't that far off, how can you take buff over Sharp Last 2 seasons: Sharp: 51 G, 59 A, 110 P, +30 Buff: 32 G, 33 A, 65 P, +0 Postseason: Sharp: 18 G, 15 A, 33 P, +9 Buff: 14 G, 11 A, 25 P, -6 That's not enough to justify Buff's ability to play mediocre at defenseman.