Yeah, I don't think he was the best. That's the point. He was targeted a lot and put up decent numbers, but in a very inefficient manner. Inefficient? He had the most yards per target on the entire team...by a decent margin. How is that not a measure of efficiency? I realize he caught a lesser % of balls thrown his way but he made up for it in YAC and YPC. I know its not the only thing, but Tell me which Bears receiver was better last year. Bennett, who didnt even see the field much the first 60% of the season? Hester, who is probably as raw or more as a receiver as Knox? Aromashadou? Not that this adds anything to my argument because you are obviously smart enough to evaluate the numbers I posted before, but this is what their stats would look like if they all had 99 targets CAT YRD TD
Knox 51 960 5
Bennett 65 792 5
Olsen 59 580 7
Hester 54 644 5 I just don't see it. Knox stands out as king of the idiots. All of these stats are pretty misleading, imo. When compared to other WRs on the Bears, Knox may have run a lot more "feast-or-famine" go routes that went for a lot of yards when a completion was made. That doesn't necessarily make him a better receiver. I'm not sold. I just don't see who is better and no one has presented an argument for anyone else. Earl Bennett might be a better route runner, but lacks the breakaway speed and overall athleticism that Knox has. I don't know how you could really make an argument for Hester, considering he has the speed and athleticism that Knox has but doesn't get the numbers Knox does. I mean other than that, unless you want to include TE and/or RB theres no real other candidates on the 10 Bears to argue for. Bennett is the only one that I'm willing to accept an argument for, and considering it took him an entire season to learn the playbook well enough to actually play in the games, I find it hard to accept that he's the best receiver on the team (last year). Actually fine, I'll play devil's advocate and make the argument for him. He's certainly a better possession receiver than Knox, and more reliable on a big down. Bennett led the Bears on 3rd down catches for a 1st down, with 12. Bennett also finished 3rd in the NFC in catches on 3rd and more than 7 yards with 7. And that's despite playing sparingly the first part of the season. Knox was 14th in the NFL with 6 dropped passes. And while Knox was 2nd in the NFC in % of targets ending in a 1st down at 43%, Bennett wasn't too far behind at 18th with 38.6%. So there, the stats are out there and if it hurts my argument, so be it.