They've been tinkering with the BCS formula for years and still haven't gotten it right...that's what worries me the most about doing it that way. They usually tinker the formula whenever an injustice occurs so it happens a year late. With the selection committee, if there's a clearly deserving team that for whatever reason doesn't do well with the computers, you have a chance to fix that immediately, instead of a year too late. I'm sure one of the reasons why they are doing this is because there is more drama for more teams going into the last weeks, as opposed to having (hypothetically) 3 undefeated teams and 6 1 loss teams. In previous years, the team who is last in the BCS 1 loss team totem pole has pretty much no hope unless they have a huge game left to play or there are a lot of upsets above them. With a selection committee, each of those teams have hope that they will be selected. I dunno, I'm not in love with the idea of a selection committee, and I know they are going to [expletive] it up at times, but I can also see some benefits to it in theory.