There was almost no argument. I remember a small minority of people saying they should keep Kyle as QB because they were winning and he was a great game manager for that defense, but that is idiotic and those people's opinions don't count because they are idiots. And Rex wasn't similarly unproven, he was a first round pick in his 3rd year in the NFL, and although those first 2 years were full of injuries he still had at least 4 starts coming into that game. Kyle was a 4th round pick and a rookie.