140 AB's does not make a season, arguably. It was one time. You tell me if it was a fluke or not. And you're judging him based on 119 bad at-bats this season. You're being really, really oblivious (obtuse? are you calling me obtuse, Dufresne?). I'm basing my rational on his entire career, minors included, not just 2007. SS Ryan was, however, basing his on one season. I have no clue where you're getting this one season thing from. You claimed that Murton hasn't posted a 425 SLG% since A ball. I responded to inform you that he hasn't slugged below 425 since low A ball. This over seasons of 455, 487, and 455 ABs. I honest to God have no clue where your numbers are coming from. Ironically enough, you're arguing for me asking if the one time the numbers were different were a fluke. Well the one time the numbers were different was when he didn't slug at an okayish rate.