It's correct to give him an error. If he would have caught the ball, Young would have not been able to advance to 3rd. The ruling is correct. No. It's a bad call. The ball landed right in front of his catcher's mitt while he was in need of performing a sweep tag. Asking a catcher to field that ball cleanly with a catcher's mitt while also trying to make the tag is not an error. You can give Soriano an error for not catching the ball or Castro on the relay or thowing it at all before you can blame the catcher for trying to perform a miracle. Exactly. How Soriano doesn't get an error despite the ball hitting him in the middle of the glove I don't know. Yes, he was up on the wall, but the ball hit him in the glove. 4 years and Soriano is still terrified of that wall.