Ignoring defense, sure. But like Dunn and Hawpe, their defense really hurts their value and, depending on cost, are possibly less valuable than Kosuke. Kubel: .907 OPS; -20 UZR/150 Cuddyer: .862 OPS; -10.1 UZR/150 Kosuke: .796 OPS; 18.2 UZR/150 (OPS is from 2009; UZR/150 is career as a right fielder) If Kuble can repeat that .907 OPS, then he's definitely on the list. It's nearly 100 points better than he's ever hit before, though. If he drops back to low-.800s, high-.700s like much of his career, Kosuke is better. If I am not mistaken Kubel's lefty vs. righty splits are atrocious. That means Kubel is best sited for splitting the starting duties for a team because when he is batting against the type of pitcher he sucks against he is completely worthless due to his defense. I am not in favor of a bad defensive OF who is worthless against one type of pitcher. I will put in the disclaimer that I have never looked at Dye's nor Giles' splits. Regardless I had forgotten about Nady before so I would just stcik with Colvin for a month. Then when Nady is back if Colvin is struggling go with Nady. Again though this is only if we get to take 9-10 million of the books in a Fukudome trade.