Frank Thomas played 969 @ 1B He was principally the first basement from 1990-1997 before he became a full time DH, so let's just count those year's fWAR. From 1990-1997 Frank Thomas accrued 48.7 fWAR Paul Konerko, arguably the only other contender for this prestigious honor, accrued 23.2 fWAR over his entire career of 18 years in a White Sox uniform. Even if we go 1990-1994, which includes the strike shortened season, Thomas put up 30 fWAR. And that was 100% offensive based, even playing 1B. His defensive metrics on FanGraphs are atrocious. During that 8 year time frame of 1990-1997, FG's combined defensive rating on Thomas was -132.0. Despite this colossal failure of a number, his bat was so good he put up four 7 WAR seasons from 1990-1997 and six total 6.0+ WAR seasons. During that stretch only two players in major league baseball were more valuable than Frank Thomas : Ken Griffey, Jr. and Barry Bonds, and only Bonds was rated a better hitter than Thomas was during that time. Frank Thomas was horsefeathering awesome and is, and always will be, the White Sox best first baseman and it's laughable they are so desperate for content they needed to put it to a vote.