i wasn't going to bother the first time you said it, but since this makes twice... who is to say any of that would've played out the same had he kicked, especially since not kicking resulted in them getting the ball where they did? it probably wouldn't have. going for the TD was fine. No, it was a bad decision. They were still down eight and would have need another scoring drive. They had next to zero chance to actually convert the TD. It was a very bad decision.