No, they aren't. But you implied that he was both good and starting caliber. He is not. Soriano is an everyday type of LF, but he's not elite. Pie is an everyday CF, if both your corner OF spots are highly productive, the Cubs' are not. Jones is a decent platoon option, if the rest of your OF is settled. Murton is a nice cheap corner OF with decent production, if the rest of your OF is settled. Floyd is a good role player who can help out in LF if CF and RF are settled. Most really good offenses have at least one everyday natural OF who routinely puts up 900+ OPS numbers, and at least one guy who, if he isn't great in the OPS department, does have really good OBP. The Cubs have nobody that fits either bill, and the closest they do have is currently the 5th OF (Murton with the OBP). They could easily go through 2007 without a single OF putting up an OPS+ in excess of 105-110 (above average).