It helps when you get to close in Pro Player. I notice you seem to concentrate exclusively on his last two years, the two he spent in Florida, but ignore he gave up 10 HR in 78 innings in Aneheim and gave up 8 in just 64 IP the year before that. He's a flyball pitcher who walks too many guys, that's just not a good combination, unless you have a terrific K rate, which he does not. And there's no point in just talking about his "closing career". He's a relief pitcher. He's been a relief pitcher throughout his career and has plenty of pre-Florida relief pitching stats to talk about his career as a whole. Pulling out his two best years and saying that's obviously who he really is and who he will stay in his 30's just doesn't make sense. Second tier relief pitchers just aren't consistently effective. A 1-2 year period of success doesn't mean anything.