Here we go again. After all the rumors about trading Hoerner last offseason, you want to trade the only hitter on the team who understands the value of putting the ball into play.
Kelly had a total of 4.1 WAR over 9 seasons before this year. He was signed to be a backup C and was leading the league in OPS certainly qualifies as a surprise. Boyd had a total of 9.7 WAR over 7 years before this one and hadn't pitched over 80 innings for the last 5 seasons and now is in the running for the Cy Young award. Pomeranz had 2 good years in the 15 years before this one. This year he had weeks of not giving up any runs. Palencia never showed much in his ml career and now he is a shut-down closer for a playoff bound team. The Brewers certainly have had surprise players who have exceeded their expectations, but The Cubs have too.
There are always surprise players that exceed expectations when a team is doing well. On the Cubs you have players like Kelly, Pomeranz, Palencia, and Boyd.
The number one thing he had to do was get a SP. The last time Soroka was an effective SP was 2019 and he has a history of arm problems. Bieber was out there if he wanted to take a gamble.
Sometimes I think the Cubs get players with the thought that they will get a hometown discount after the player falls in love with Wrigley and the fans.
The 80% that worry more about profit than winning are probably small-to-middle market teams. We should be compared to the major market teams and not Sacramento/Oakland or Kansas City.
"My biggest disagreement with several posters is I just don’t see it as a foregone conclusion they aren’t even going to be competitive for him." The question is whose definition of "being competitive" are we going to use. According to the Cubs, they have made "competitive offers" to many of the big-time FAs over the years.