whether or not he "outperforms" the other "fifth starters" does not matter. Slotting pitchers and saying "oh he's a fine ____ slot starter" is worthless. If you slot each spot at league average then guess what kind of team you're going to be? Average. Big deal... On the other hand look at this way, is he better than Guzman? Probably not. Is he better than Marshall? Maybe. Is he better than Marmol? Maybe. If he's our fifth starter and we signed him for two million dollars that we can easily write off when Guzman's excelling in AAA (which is likely) that's one thing. But no, he's signed to an albatross of a three year contrat that can't be "eaten" at any point due to Jim Hendry's [expletive] misunderstanding of the concept of money. You're asking me to compare him to the rest of the league's fifth starters when we're paying him seven mil? He's not even the seventh best starter on our team and we gave him 21 mil over three years. Christ. (Z, Prior, Hill, Lilly, Miller, Guzman are all guys I'd say are better without a doubt). I have no idea if there are 150 starters out there who will outperform him, I do know that the Cubs have 7-8 guys who would outperform him or at least perform as good as him. That's all that matters.