Oh lord no. Guaranteed elimination games are awesome. Nobody is dying to see the Game 1 of 3 between the Angels and Royals while the whole playoffs get pushed back a week. Yeah, a best of 3 makes no [expletive] sense. Makes it marginally (and I mean marginally) less of a crapshoot and drags it out and removes the amazigness of single elimination. How many best-of-three series did the cubs win a single game to start the year? You are giving a greater margin-for-error for the best team to advance. Is it still a crapshoot? Yeah. Does it make it less likely that it's not a coin toss? Yeah. Marginal or not, it would only "cost" one or two additional days. Not to mention I'd bet that ratings and viewership would be high, regardless. Exciting and fun factor of a one game playoff >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> that very marginal removal of variance It's opinion and I realize that. I guess I'm just pessimistically thinking about the scenario when the cubs are the superior team and get screwed out of advancing because of some scrub pitcher having the game of his life. Give them a series to figure it out. But, agree to disagree. I understand both views.