I'm actually for signing Lofton if we don't get Giles. I think full years of Giles and Murton are big enough upgrades that as long as we get healthy years from the MI (Walker, Nomar/Furcal), we can afford Corey in the lineup. If we have to sign Burnitz again (or another retread like him), then I think we should pick up Lofton, and hope he can play half a season as well as he did last year. Of course, if we're stuck with Cedeno/Neifi at ss, and Murton in left, I think we have to look at any possible upgrades, whether it be Lofton, Preston Wilson, whatever.