Leaving aside what I think about your list, we're not talking about who the best pitcher is right now. We're talking about who, if you're a major league ballclub, are the most valuable pitchers to own. That involves the short-term and the long-term and everything else in between. And all I've said is that, when healthy (long enough to get into a groove, I should have added), Mark Prior is one of the top three starting pitchers in the game period (yes, Rocket, my top three is Santana, Peavy and Prior), and that the health "risk" involved with him is nowhere near great enough to justify bumping him off a list of the game's 50 best assets. If you want to debate that you're going to either come up with an argument that there are many more pitchers better than him when he's at his best, or an argument that he's such an injury risk that that's irrelevant. A list of pitchers that had good years last year doesn't achieve either. More valuabe than Prior: Z Santana Buerhle Peavy Willis Oswalt