The only fair thing I can think of is to not allow any points earned by the added player until the illegal roster has been fixed. Thoughts? I'm not sure if there's a better solution than that. I think Chuck jumped the gun and assumed he'd be placed on the DL when in fact he has not. On the flip side, he still has Longoria, who is on the major league DL, in his lineup. Well that kind of changes things a bit. I think if he just corrects his roster with placing Longoria on the DL, Holliday on the bench and picking up a 3b he'd technically be okay. It would have been legal for him to bench Holliday since he is hurt. That also allows him to add a player provided he stays legal, which moving Longoria to the DL would have allowed. Then when he adds a 3b, he'll have to figure out who he wants to drop. Does the commish have the ability to put Longoria on the DL, Holliday on the bench, and Chuck will lose points every day he does not have a replacement? If we are of the opinion that this is a legitimate goof, then that's what should be done. But at some point players who are illegally placed on the DL should be removed from the team and made a free agent. Then whoever wants to claim them on waivers can do so.