It's been pretty obvious that Guillen is at least his equal, and a cursory look at the numbers tells you Carlos is better. Guillen - 23, 8, 26, 18 WS Jeter - 26, 26, 33, 20 WS Guillen - 102, 42, 107, 89 RC Jeter - 99, 106, 138, 97 RC Guillen is underrated for sure but he still hasn't been as valuable as Jeter over the last 4 years partially because of the fact he gets banged up some every year but also because OBP is more valuable than SLG and Jeter has had close to .400 OBP over the past 3 years.