Right now, probably Rolen by a hair (not as good offensively, but much better fielder and probably a better baserunner). But A-Ram is younger and hasn't had the major injury ROlen has had (although ARam has been on the DL plenty), so if I were building a team, I'd take A-ram. And Aram is at the age and talent level where he could have a really over performing breakout year like Lee did last year. I'd rather have Aram. If he's out a month again this year. That would change though. But you see IMO our offense might actually be a bit better than the Cards if Murton and Cedeno do pan out well.