you're uncharacteristically reading far too much into a small sample size because of confirmation bias currently, the average 1B in the MLB posts a .761; a reasonable babip and hr/fb still puts him in the neighborhood of what Mike Napoli's doing now, which is league-average 1B offense but sure, look at the 1B situation for Cleveland, Miami, LA Dodgers, Seattle, Pittsburgh (they're playing Casey Mcgehee there), NY Mets and tell me with a straight face he'll wash out of the league