No chance that happens. One side will point out the fact that Prior gets hurt too much, and the other will busily try and point out that Miggy has character issues. And I would never trade Prior for Miggy. You can find a Miggy. It's harder to find #1 starters. This argument is as old as baseball, but I take the other side. A pitcher at his best can only help you win 20% of the team's games. A position player can help you win 100% of your team's games. Further, in this case, I'm not so sure Prior is a #1 pitcher anymore. And even if he recovers to his 2003 form, Cabrera is already, at age 23, one of the five best hitters in the game. I'd do Prior for Cabrera in a heartbeat, but I don't think the Fish would, and I KNOW Jim Hendry doesn't have the cajones for it. But it would improve the team. I think it's robbing Peter to pay Paul. You weaken your pitching, but improve your offense, so IMO it's a wash. And besides, per Roast we're only supposed to decide between dealing for Abreu and signing Giles in this thread :P . So we'll have to take this one elsewhere.