I disagree that pointing out other slow starts is an excuse. I like Aramis, and I root for him, but if I thought he was going to continue his poor hitting, I'd be happy to see him replaced. There's good reason to believe he won't continue playing poorly. As for being pull-happy, if he really is adversely affecting his game by trying to pull too many pitches, then you have every right to criticize his performance. I think it's stupid to jump on a player who's slumping unless they're obviously doing something wrong that could be corrected. For example, Sammy in 2004 was standing a zip code away from the plate and couldn't reach outside pitches. He deserved criticism when he slumped. All of Aramis's hits at Wrigley this year have been to the left side of the field. If Aramis needs to hit the ball to the opposite field to get himself going, then I'm all for it. However, while he does have extra base power to all fields, the vast majority of his homers at Wrigley are to left field. I love Matt Murton - I'm excited everytime I see one of his atbats - but I don't want Aramis to try to be Matt.