It seems to be a "When you think Cubs, who are the first three players that come to mind?" kind of list. So yeah, Banks, Sosa, Williams, Sandberg make sense. Santo if it were a Cub fan only poll.
There's never a good time for injury, but Braun's injury couldn't have been better timed for the Brewers, playing the punchless Nats and Pads coming up. If there are any games that an offense can absorb the loss of a player like that, it's those kind of games.
Here's a clip of the last leg of the race. The announcers go from already having conceded first to the French to practically Gus Johnson in a 20 second clip.
I'd almost prefer a completely separate wing of "Players good enough statistically to be in the hall, but who did something really stupid to compromise the integrity of the game." Then put guys like Jackson, Rose, and the HGH squad in there so they can be remembered for both the good and the bad.
Is defensive efficiency calculated by fielding percentages? Just trying to figure out if maybe that has something to do with it... Fielding percentage is only a part of it. Another part of it is the percentage of balls that fielders get to that are hit towards them, or in their area, as well as balls they get to that are technically out of their zone (referred to as OOZ in metrics). Using fielding percentage as a comparative tool is a restrictive statistic because it assumes everyone has the same range.
Without checking (right now, I can only seem to access this site from work), I think the Cubs were #1 in defensive efficiency last year. This year, I believe the Cardinals are #1, and the Cubs are either #2 or #3.
Just for the record, I don't like the idea of Marmol walking anyone on purpose. He already has enough trouble with that on accident, and nobody really hits bloop singles off him anyway.