I count two posters that were in favor of trading for Carmelo at basically any cost, and one of them thought that Rose wasn't a #1 player on a championship team and Noah was a role player, and the other thought Deng was awful and beyond useless. The general consensus was that if Deng was going to continue to take awful shots and miss half the season, Anthony would provide the shooting that a terrible Bulls shooting team coming into the season would need. Almost nobody was willing to part with Noah for him, but wanted the team to be able to work out a deal involving Deng and possibly Gibson for him, sacrificing defense (which the Bulls excelled at even last year) for offense (which the Bulls were just flat out awful at last year). Turns out, though, that Deng can be good when he doesn't take all low-percentage shots (although it'd be nice if there were another viable SF on the roster so Thibs wouldn't run him into the ground), Rose has progressed into a superstar, Boozer provides just the kind of low-post offense the Bulls needed, and Thibs knows how to draw up actual offenses in ways VDN couldn't even dream about. The glaring need is now at SG, and getting consistent offensive threat out of a guard other than Rose. Korver does that, but there's not enough Korver to get offense for the whole game.