bukie
-
Posts
20,386 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
20
Content Type
Profiles
Joomla Posts 1
Chicago Cubs Videos
Chicago Cubs Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits
2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospects Ranking
News
2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks
Guides & Resources
2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks
The Chicago Cubs Players Project
2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Pick Tracker
Blogs
Events
Forums
Store
Gallery
Everything posted by bukie
-
I think I still might take Garnett over Noah this year (in terms of basketball ability), but certainly Noah going forward. If Pau counts as a center, I'd take him ahead of Noah, too. Love is also a really good player, and is in the discussion. Noah is a top 25 NBA player, though, for sure, and a definite all-star.
-
WARP, PER, WS82, WS/48 work for you, then? Not really. Numbers are nice but just because baseball has been boiled down to an equation doesn't mean basketball stats are nearly as descriptive. Melo's easily more than "not very valuable" So what you're saying is you like numbers until they disagree with you, and then they are useless to you. Hell, there are even numbers that suggest that Melo's value this year is less than Billups'. The primary reason all these metrics are valuing Carmelo so low is that his sole value is in his shooting, and he hasn't done that well this year. Thus the reference to his TS%. Rather than look solely at this year, though, I thought it'd be fairer to look at his projections over the next 3 years, as he's quite certainly having an off year this year. To see him behind so many players in WARP projections is odd, which is why I don't consider him a top 10 player. Top 25, sure, but not top 10.
-
When the alternative is an overpaid Deng coming off 3 subpar years, a player like Anthony being available is a major step up. After 6 months of sustained good play from Deng, and a drop-off from Melo, even a straight-up swap wasn't so obvious anymore. Carmelo Anthony is a really good one-on-one iso offensive player. He's also a decent rebounder. He does nothing else, though, and when all you do is shoot and your TS% is comparative to Jamal Crawford and Kirk Hinrich, you are not very valuable. And Derrick Rose, too. Don't forget about him. ETA: I was being a wise ass. No dissertations on the greatness of Derrick Rose please. Holy taking a quote out of context, batman. Might want to consider the whole sentence.
-
Discussions with the Rockets about Courtney Lee, but the Rockets want Asik in return.
-
WARP, PER, WS82, WS/48 work for you, then?
-
When the alternative is an overpaid Deng coming off 3 subpar years, a player like Anthony being available is a major step up. After 6 months of sustained good play from Deng, and a drop-off from Melo, even a straight-up swap wasn't so obvious anymore. Carmelo Anthony is a really good one-on-one iso offensive player. He's also a decent rebounder. He does nothing else, though, and when all you do is shoot and your TS% is comparative to Jamal Crawford and Kirk Hinrich, you are not very valuable.
-
Not better than them at what? Basketball. Just a quick eyeball, based on the 50 players Bill Simmons listed in his "Most Valuable players" trade column, here are the ones projected to be more valuable via WARP than Anthony over the next 3 years (keep in mind, the next 3 years is the heart of Anthony's prime): Dwight Howard, LeBron James, Kevin Durant, Derrick Rose, Dwyane Wade, Blake Griffin, Eric Gordon, Chris Paul, Kevin Love, Kobe Bryant, Stephen Curry, Rajon Rondo, Josh Smith, Manu Ginobili, Deron Williams, Pau Gasol, Al Horford, Andrew Bynum, John Wall, Monta Ellis, Kevin Martin, Serge Ibaka, Tim Duncan, Tyreke Evans, Amare Stoudamire, Kevin Garnett, LaMarcus Aldridge, Andrew Bogut, Danny Granger, Tony Parker and Joakim Noah (who is only projected to play 50 games per season). Now, I don't necessarily agree with all of them, but to say he's easily a top 10 player is just an outright fallacy.
-
Well this is shorting Carmelo quite a bit because he's at least Dirk and Durant's equal on defense. Rose is a better passer, but he's not a better rebounder and they are equal at shooting. Carmelo is quite easily a Top 10 player. No, it's really not shorting Carmelo at all. Carmelo is not better than Rose, Dirk, Durant, Gasol, Williams or Paul. He's sure as hell not better than James, Howard, Wade or Bryant. He's probably not better than Westbrook, Pierce, Rondo, Garnett, Amare, Nash or Love, either.
-
Of course, with D-Will in tow, the Nets could make a solid case for Dwight Howard when he enters FA.
-
In my opinion, these are the top 10 players in the NBA right now: LeBron James, Dwight Howard, Dwyane Wade, Kobe Bryant, Kevin Durant, Chris Paul, Derrick Rose, Dirk Nowitzki, Deron Williams and Pau Gasol. Not necessarily in that order, but around that order. After that, you've got guys like Westbrook, Garnett, Rondo, Pierce, Ginobili, Parker, Carmelo, Noah, Amare, Bosh, Horford, Aldridge, Love, Boozer and even Blake Griffin in some order.
-
Funniest comment I've seen on the deal: "Great news for all those Nets fans who bought Terrence Williams jerseys when he was a rookie."
-
Not sure about that. I do think that the Nets got a better player than the Knicks did this week, and gave up less going forward.
-
Second Nets trade: Troy Murphy to Golden State for Dan Gadzuric.
-
Derrick Favors, Devin Harris, and two firsts to the Jazz.
-
Utah has just traded Deron Williams to the Nets.
-
Not necessarily, now it'll probably just be the Knicks instead of the Sixers.
-
Nope, but I also thought if we shot as well as we did we would be in the game. Didn't you? Hard to stay in a game when you play no defense and turn the ball over 18 times.
-
We will be in the NIT. And lose in either the 1st or 2nd round. They're easily in the tournament if they beat Indiana and Iowa at home, and don't lose to a bad team in the Big Ten tournament. You are assuming every good small school wins their tourny. No, that would be borderline. Did anyone seriously think they'd win tonight?
-
We will be in the NIT. And lose in either the 1st or 2nd round. They're easily in the tournament if they beat Indiana and Iowa at home, and don't lose to a bad team in the Big Ten tournament.
-
If you allow twice as many shots as you take, it doesn't matter how well you shoot, you will lose.
-
Illini may want to pick up the defensive intensity a bit, because those 3's are eventually going to stop falling.
-
That and he was way too far under the basket to get a charge call. Awful call.
-
Wood for mayor of Chicago!
-
Since Toronto got the 1st rounder for Bosh, and they never used it, they essentially traded Bosh for JJ.
-
Bulls trade James Johnson to Toronto for a first round pick: http://sports.espn.go.com/chicago/nba/news/story?id=6148430&d I'm mostly surprised they got a first rounder for JJ. It was obvious Thibs wasn't going to use him, so might as well get something for him.
