Nearly any manager should've been able to win with the Cubs in 2003 and 2004. They had a solid lineup 1-8 and the best rotation 1-5 in baseball. Dusty turned what should've been a budding Cub dynasty with a stacked farm system of pitching into crap in just 3 years. At least Piniella can say he managed the Cubs to be easily the best team in the NL in 2008. I don't know if we can call the 2003-2004 team a budding Cubs dynasty. Maybe by 2004 since Lee, Ramirez, and Barrett had shown up, but that 2003 team was going to need almost all the major offensive pieces replaced very quickly. And the farm system was not nearly as stacked as had been thought. Dusty ruined the young pitching which was a huge blow, but the Cubs were still going to have to make a lot of good moves to become elite going forward. In 2003-2004, they had a rotation of mid-20s pitchers in Prior, Wood, Zambrano and Clement, along with a pen of young arms in Farnsworth, Wuertz, Cruz, and even Todd Wellemeyer, Francis Beltran and Jon Leicester. Their oldest arm in the pen was LaTroy Hawkins, who was totally unfairly remembered on that squad and possibly the best reliever they had. On the offensive front, they had quickly morphed from a team with Sosa and Alou and little else by trading for or signing Ramirez, Lee, Barrett, Todd Walker, and a 30-year-old Nomar Garciaparra. Patterson getting injured and coming back slowly had killed them in CF, but they still had guys like Murton waiting in the wings. Poor positional drafting probably hurt them long-term more than anything on the offensive end, since the players they acquired to take over for Alou/Sosa/Patterson either were expected to be something they weren't (Murton, Jones, Soriano, Fukudome) or just old and/or bad from the start (Hollandsworth, Burnitz, Grieve, Lawton, Pierre, Nevin, Floyd).