Notre Dame definitely looked better against Army on the road than PSU looked against Minnesota. Granted, I think Army was significantly over-ranked based on not having lost yet (i.e. I think Minnesota is actually a better team than Army), but I'm mostly just trying to figure out why PSU doesn't deserve their spot over some of these other teams, or now that Indiana lost to Ohio State they don't deserve to be in the playoffs either, as if the SEC just is by default better than anyone else despite not really having shown much to support this other than their purchased support from ESPN.
I'd definitely prefer to see, like, SMU and Miami both in the playoff over, say, 3-loss Alabama, even if they did beat up Wisconsin and squeaked by Georgia.
Just for posterity, this would be my top 12 right now:
1. Ohio State - Yes, they lost to Oregon, in Oregon, by one point. I think the rest of their resume is more impressive overall, and I think they'd be favored right now in a neutral environment that we'll see in two weeks anyway.
2. Oregon - They'll get a chance at OSU again, most likely. Win again, and there's no doubt they're #1.
3. Notre Dame - Inexplicable loss to NIU. Just bonkers. Still have the best win among the 1 loss teams and continue looking impressive week in, week out.
4. Texas - Explain to me a second what Texas' best win is? Is it at 6-5 Vandy or at 6-5 Michigan? They have a shot at a good win next week, but that will just give a direct point of reference against ND.
5. Penn State - Lost a close one to Ohio State at home, like they do every year. Beat everyone else, sometimes impressively, sometimes not. Boring team, but consistently good and beat everyone but Ohio State.
6. Georgia - Two losses, one bad, one close. Three good wins, which IMO puts them ahead of Indiana, Miami or SMU. Probably would be favored against Texas on a neutral field and would climb up to the #2 seed if they win the SEC.
7. Miami - See Texas. Miami's best win is probably at Louisville, as there are 3 good ACC teams and none of them play each other in the regular season.
8. Indiana - Yes, they lost by 23 to Ohio State. They've also beat up almost everyone else they've played, and have earned their way into the playoff discussion.
9. SMU - Same as Miami, but their loss was to a better team, but haven't been as impressive in wins. Maybe a straight pick-em vs Miami in a potential ACC championship, winner gets a mostly undeserving 3 seed.
10. Tennessee - This was probably A&M until that last Auburn loss. Good win against Bama, but their record is buoyed by their forgiving schedule more than most SEC teams.
11. Boise State - Gets the nod over whoever is the best team left in the Big 12. Still won't be ranked higher than anyone they'd potentially play in the playoff.
12. Arizona State - I guess? What's happening in this conference this season?