good for 1.7 WAR in 129 games Because he was bad defensively. 8 of the 9 starters had OPS+ of 109 or better (Patterson was 96). The Cubs got 9 starts all year from a pitcher that didn't finish with an ERA+ under 110 (Mitre pitched 9 starts and did terrible). LaTroy Hawkins had a 168 ERA+, Mercker, Remlinger, Leicester, and Wuertz all pitched at least 30 games in relief and posted above average ERA+. Basically Farnsworth got 72 appearances and wasn't that good, and Dusty had a bench full of Dusty favorites that he kept giving plate appearances to that had no business on a major league roster (Ordonez, Macias, Goodwin, Gonzalez).