Peavy has no shot of winning the Cy Young. Brandon Webb has very little shot of NOT winning the Cy Young. He has the wins, and all his numbers are good enough to justify it without much question. My vote would go for Lincecum. If you like Ks, he will lead the NL in that. If you like ERA, he leads the NL in that. If you value wins, then you have to value the fact that he will likely finish with the fewest losses of any starting pitcher, and he's on a bad team. If you like durability, he will finish top 5 in innings. A name that has been strangely quiet this year, but has put up numbers nearly identical (actually slightly better) than Webb is Johan Santana, who has put up a 2.27 ERA since June. Webb and Santana have thrown the exact same innings (2nd to Hamels), have given up the exact same number of hits and are within 4 in Ks, BBs allowed, and ERs. Dempster has been amazing, but one could argue him as the 7th best pitcher in the NL this year, behind Webb, Santana, Haren, Lincecum, Volquez and Peavy. Hamels, Zambrano and Billingsley are a strong finish away from getting their names in the discussion, but it's probably a little too late for them.