Why is this stupid? I think it's stupid because they are selling low. I agree with the article; that it might have been better to hold on to him in hopes of increasing his value instead of immediately settling for a few middling pieces this early (they may have gotten that ultimately but it makes little since to do so now. The Pirates will have an up hill battle in the division as it is and I don't see how any of those players will help). Waiting to trade him would have at least giving them a better chance to increase his value. Reasonable answer. I think there are a couple of other things going on. One, I think his elbow could be done. Someone above was mentioning his general stats weren't off that much last year, but there was something missing that didn't show up in the stat sheet. Second, he became a bit of a distraction last year with his grievance. I'm not judging the grievance right or wrong, just saying it was a distraction. Third, from what I'm reading now, it seems he showed up out of shape last year. Nothing was written last year, and I don't know why this is coming out now. But, he basically admitted it. Yeah, we could have waited, but, of course, there's always a down side to this also. Note that Huntington is holding off on dealing Bay for this very reason.