Wow! Such hand wringing and teeth gnashing, and I only got to page 6! I didn't read the other 29 pages inbetween, so I'm most likely going to post what other people said. I think, at worst, this trade is almost a non-issue. First, I don't think his salary is an issue. Yeah, he's making 13 mil, but the Pirates are picking up 5.5 of it and the seasons > 1/2 over. And, Oakland threw in some cash. And, this is the final year of the contract, so there's no long term commitment. You gave up a DFA'd catcher and a low minor league reliever, someone who was projected as a specialist? In other words, you gave up a guy you had given up on anyway, and a potential bit contributor for an experienced catcher. OK, So, Kendall can't hit anymore. He usually comes on strong in the second 1/2, so, maybe he'll hit .250 for you guys if your lucky. And his defense? Not great either. But, he'll call a better game than either Soto or Hill. With the offense you guys have, the game calling alone could be enough to put you over the top. Or not. I don't think you guys hurt yourself long term, and I don't think you made the team worse. And, the potential is there to have made your team better. Not earth shattering, but a good trade, I think.