Soriano should have been put in RF and Murton in LF. Soriano has the skill set for RF much more than Murton or Floyd does. Agreed. And signing Floyd was a terrible idea from the get-go. In theory, there was nothing wrong with signing Floyd. He could spell Murton against the really tough righties, be a top pinch hitter, and DH in interleague play. The problem was trusting Lou to be able to maximize the utility of his players.