Hmmm.... 1) Eddie Collins 2) Ryno 3) Rogers Hornsby 4) Napoleon Lajoie 5) Biggio or ....hate to say it Joe Morgan black Americans might take issue with someone missing from that list, as might fans of the Detroit Tigers. Yankee fans might also, but who really gives a rat's tail about them. Dang, you're on to my covert racism....thus why I didn't have Joe Morgan higher. :) Jackie Robinson was a great player but the numbers aren't even close to him being a top 5 great at that position compared to the others I listed. I understand he lost years to the war and a few years in the Negro leagues, but calculating that into an equation just doesn't work. Otherwise we'd still have Ty Cobb as the all time hit leader due to his years lost in WWI or with Ted Williams being top 3 in homers if he hadn't lost years in WWII and Korea. By the Tiger I assume you mean Whitaker, who'd I'd have in the top 10, but he's not better than Collins, Lajoie, Hornsby, Ryno, or Morgan. The Yankee I'd take you to be talking about Lazerri? He didn't even have 2000 hits in 14 seasons. Don't forget, Jackie may have played more at 2B than any other position, but he only played about half his games there. Is he a 2B? Yeah... but it's kinda unfair to give him credit for his career numbers at a skill position when he wasn't playing there for a good chunk of his career. And yeah, I do say the same thing when talking about Ernie Banks while making greatest SS arguments.