If the Cubs sign Furcal but miss out on a Giles-like upgrade in RF, the Cubs won't have any better of a shot at making the playoffs than they did this season. That's insane. If we don't get Giles or someone better we're not making the playoffs? Healthy rotation, bullpen help, and we make the playoffs no matter who we sign for right. So, if tomorrow Giles signs with the Yankees and the Reds and Phillies announce that Dunn and Abreu, respectively, are off the table and will not be traded, Hendry should completely shut down his offseason operations? Add Furcal and Pierre at the top of the lineup. Get some luck, healthwise. Add a top starting pitcher and a top setup reliever. Add someone like Kearns or Wilkerson (maybe both - I've heard rumblings that the Cubs may not be 100% committed to just completely turning LF over to Murton). A team like that is absolutely guaranteed to be no better than .500? Give me a break. Try giving the hyperbole a rest. All that said - sign Giles!