Please don't assume I'm easy on steriod testing. I'm not. I would not have qualms at all about an 81 game regular-season suspension (including a post-season ban if applicable) for the first offense, 162 games for the second, and life for the third. However, I'm also a firm believer in "everyone deserves a second chance" in society in most cases. If you murder someone in cold blood? No, you don't. However, if you do something like illegal drugs, I am ok with someone getting a second chance after a punishment. However, I have problems with third, fourth, fifth chances. But if Rookie Player A takes Over-the-counter Suppliment "B", and the 34th ingredient on the bottle contains one extremely small metric measurement of "Not illegal but banned by MLB substance nobody has ever heard of except doctors or scientists", do I believe that player should be banned for life? No. Punished? Yes, but that player deserves a second chance if it was an honest mistake. However, if Veteran player A jabs a needle full of banned substance B into his ass, knowing full well what he's doing, then yes, I have no problem with a lifetime ban. Unfortuantely, since you can't take it case by case, I think you need to be harsh (but not extremely harsh) in a first offense. MLB should update the banned substances list 3 times per year, and should make a copy available to every player on every team in thier native language for them to keep, as well as to minor leaguers on the 40-man rosters. Then, as you said, it would be up to the players to see what is in the suppliments, etc, that they're putting in thier bodies, and check it on the list.