There are plenty of Neifie is a crappy player shields to hide behind. OBP is but one. How about batting average, walks, hit into DPs, SLG, or VORP. Those are only a sample of other shields. In fact I could make a fortress of crappy stats to hide behind when it comes to Perez. Many teams that won have had crappy short stops. That does not mean that it is a formula on which to rely or even a good idea. Bottom line, Neifie is one of the worst offensive short stops to play on a regular basis in the past 20 years.