The fact is, if this team is going to compete next year, wholesale upgrades are necessary. 1B is one of the best places to do so with the best available options, unless we want to spend similar money on a perenially injured Jose Reyes or a bit less on a 35 year old Carlos Beltran. Sabathia would also be an intriguing option, but a very expensive one, but The Tigers have shown us how valuable it is to have one shutdown ace no matter how meh the rest of your pitching staff is, of course we don't have the Tigers offense. I know, Penas a great clubhouse guy, but 10 mil is a steep price for a youth mentor. Couple things: - 35 year old Beltran will cost alot less than Pujols/Fielder. That said, he should only be an option AFTER bringing one of those two in. He'd be a great piece to the puzzle, but only if a really big key piece is there to help make him a secondary acquisition rather than a primary one. - The Tigers' offense has 5 of 9 starters currently posting above average OPS'. It's built around one superstar bat (Cabrera), a couple solid vets (Martinez, Peralta), and then a couple of upstart young guys (Boesch and Avila). I think the 2012 Cubs can pull that off if they added a superstar bat. There's talented bats in this lineup (Ramirez, Castro, Soto, and to a much much lesser extent nowadays Soriano), but no one to spearhead the operation of destroying other teams' pitching. - Agreed that Sabathia is a pipedream. To throw some optimism into that situation....He really liked the NL, he really liked hitting, and the NL would give him a great chance to put up some HOF type numbers to close out a potentially HOF career (which might have a good 8-10 years on it, maybe).