yes that's true, but one also has to assume that luck will even out over time. some months theriot will have more singles drop in and be a very productive player; other months those batted balls will be caught more frequently and he'll have very little value. he's drawn 69 walks in 641 PAs this year, which is a rate comparable to lee and ramirez. i don't know why pitchers would walk him, but they have been this year, and i think the cat has been out of the bag for quite a while on him not being a power hitter. he's in the bottom 20 in baseball in frequency swinging at pitches; most guys in this group are guys you'd expect to see - cust, dunn, abreu, swisher. he's 7th in baseball in zone%, which i'm pretty sure means percent of pitches he sees within the strike zone. so pitchers throw him a lot of strikes, but he still manages to walk a lot. it's strange, but i don't think the spread is that large between the # of strikes that theriot sees and the # of strikes that a guy like adam dunn sees. pitchers probably don't vary their approach as much as they should. of course it's unfair. he's a little below average, but people make him out to be a complete butcher. he makes a very high percentage of plays on balls hit to him or in his area; his range is limited and his arm is fringy. this ends up making him a little below average. just because he made an error in an important spot that you remember does not make him any worse of a defensive player. overall, he'll give you above-average obp and below-average power at his position, plus a little below-average defense. he is essentially to shortstop what matt murton was to corner outfield. in the absence of a better in-house alternative, you're probably going to need a few players like this on the roster - adequate players making the major league minimum, so that you can afford to pay the big-production veterans.