There are two kinds of mediocre free agent pitchers. There are the guys with higher strikeout rates and the "still unfilled potential" tag who can command $10 million or more per season. See Chan Ho Park, Darren Dreifort, Carl Pavano. Andy Pettitte slots in as a little better than average, but still wildly overrated and overpaid. Then there are the underappreciated mediocre starters like Suppan, Batista, Kenny Rogers for most of his career, Tim Wakefield. These guys usually have some things in common: -low strikeout rates -don't throw all that hard -never had a really great year that stands out -pitch in a hitter's park -played in fairly low profile settings (non-playoff teams, small markets, or was nothing better than a 3rd/4th starter in the playoffs) -didn't do anything really special in the playoffs (Derek Lowe would've made at least $3M less per year if not for his performance in the '04 playoffs) -rather hittable, but low walk rates -toward the middle or end of their career; no "potential" left to fulfill These are guys who can be had from the bargain bin at $3-6M per year, half of what some of the guys above are making - and the bargain guys are just as good (going by ERA+) as the overrated guys. I'm hoping the Cubs bring in one of the $5M or so bargain guys who they can count on to pitch 200 innings with an ERA+ around 100.